First Lady of the United States
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue
Washington, D.C.
June 2, 1993
Dear Hillary:
Our committee met with Dr.
We support the concept of "mandated benefits" rather than "mandated providers" in the proposed legislation. But a point of reality in health care cost must be understood. The system is MD based and MD driven, if non-MD providers are desired and not specified, it will not happen. Due to this medical monopoly, we are concerned with the prospect of a medically dominated system from the perspective of the facts which surfaced during the chiropractic profession's decade long antitrust suit with the American Medical Association. In 1987, the Supreme Court of the United States upheld the decision of Appeals Court and Federal District Court by finding the American Medical Association guilty of violating the nation's antitrust laws by engaging in a conspiracy to contain and eliminate chiropractic physicians from mainstream health care.
It is our hope that the statutory language will contain the president's guarantee that an individual who seeks care through any managed care entity (HMO) established or regulated under the president's plan shall have a right to access care and treatment from a doctor of chiropractic through the specified managed care entities and have those costs fully covered as part of the mandated benefits package. This country affords the public legal protection against age discrimination, job discrimination, gender discrimination, et cetera, through the United States Constitution. We urge your task force to consider the public welfare by guaranteeing the patient direct access to the health care of their choice. The insured individual must be afforded the most basic of rights. The right to freedom of choice to select a provider for any of the mandated benefits in accordance with that provider's individual scope of practice as specified by state statute.
A health care system that excludes chiropractic will lose the most effective means of cost containment in health care today. This profession has already proven to be up to 10 times more efficient in delivering quality health care in terms of "cost per case" and "days lost time." Inclusion of chiropractic will assure aggressive competition between provider groups. Exclusion of chiropractic from a "managed competition" based system will result in a loss of one of the most dynamic elements from the system, that of interprofessional competition for the health care dollar.
My committee and I stand ready to assist you with needed support to move this legislation to successful adoption.
Sincerely,
Stanley B. Heard, DC, chairman National Chiropractic Health Care Advisory Committee
cc: Honorable Bill Clinton, President
Ms. Carol Rasco
Mr. Bruce Lindsey
Mr. Steve Edelstein
Dr. Robert Valdez
The White House
Washington
June 4, 1993
Stanley B. Heard, DC
Multiplex Chiropractic Clinic, P.A.
251 Hobson
Hot Springs, AR 71913
Dear Stan:
Thank you for your letter in support of "mandated benefits" and the patients' right to choose their providers. Thank you also for the offer of assistance.
Let me assure you that the president's plan will protect choice of provider. As I am sure you are aware, many insurance plans today have limited choice. The president's plan will ensure that the American people have a choice of plans.
Once again, thank you for your concern, and best wishes. It's always good to hear from you.
Sincerely yours,
Hillary Rodham Clinton
Dynamic Chiropractic editorial staff members research, investigate and write articles for the publication on an ongoing basis. To contact the Editorial Department or submit an article of your own for consideration, email
.